You are here : Home | Professional Broker | Bank or mortgage broker: how to secure your home loan

Page/Post ID:59767/single | Page Lang = en

Should you use a bank or broker for your Swiss mortgage?

Bank or mortgage broker: how should you choose?

When financing a home in Switzerland, comparing a bank or mortgage broker is not simply a choice between “doing everything yourself” and “delegating the paperwork”. The difference goes much deeper: if you approach a bank directly, your project enters the decision-making system of a single lender. With a mortgage broker, the same application can be assessed against the criteria of several institutions.

Those criteria are not identical. Two lenders may recognise different levels of income, assign different values to the same property, apply different theoretical costs or accept different financing structures. The result: an offer with a slightly higher interest rate can sometimes be financially more attractive than the offer with the lowest rate.

This is what you need to understand before deciding whether it is better to use a bank or a broker to obtain a mortgage in Switzerland.

Bank or broker: you are not simply comparing two lenders

The bank assesses your application using its own criteria

A bank receiving your application is not looking for the theoretically best financing across the entire market. It checks whether your project fits its own credit policy and then determines what it is prepared to offer you.

Your bank adviser may be able to negotiate certain terms, but cannot rewrite the institution’s internal rules. If the bank recognises only part of your bonus, uses a conservative method to calculate the income of a self-employed applicant or values the property below the purchase price, those factors may matter more than a few basis points on the interest rate.

A broker looks for the criteria that best fit your application

The broker’s role is different. A broker does not lend the money and never decides whether the mortgage will be granted. However, a broker can identify among partner institutions those whose criteria are a better fit for your circumstances.

This is a decisive difference in the broker or bank comparison: the bank checks whether you fit its financing model; the broker can look for a financing model that fits your profile.

One misconception should nevertheless be avoided: a broker does not necessarily cover the entire Swiss market. Brokers compare the lenders they can access. The quality of the result therefore also depends on the breadth and relevance of that network.

The real comparison lies in the affordability calculation

To finance a home, the lender checks in particular your affordability: whether your income can sustainably cover interest, amortisation and the costs associated with the property.

The important detail is that institutions have considerable discretion in how they perform this calculation. FINMA itself notes that affordability criteria vary significantly between institutions. For owner-occupied property, for example, it regards an assessment based on a 5% theoretical interest rate, theoretical ancillary costs and an affordability ceiling as prudent. This is not, however, a single commercial formula imposed on every bank.

CHF 150’000.– of income does not always mean CHF 150’000.–

Take a household reporting total annual income of CHF 150’000.–. On paper, the figure looks perfectly straightforward. To a lender, it may be considerably less clear.

  • A variable part of salary may be recognised in full, in part or not at all.
  • A bonus may be averaged over several years rather than based on the latest year alone.
  • A self-employed person’s income may be determined from several sets of annual accounts.
  • Existing commitments, such as leasing or other loans, reduce available affordability.
  • A foreseeable change in professional or family circumstances may be taken into account.

This is why asking one bank “how much can I borrow?” gives you that bank’s answer, not necessarily the market’s answer.

In this type of situation, the question bank or mortgage broker matters far more than simply comparing published interest rates online.

The value assigned to the property can transform the financing

The price agreed at the notary is not enough

Another Swiss mechanism deserves much more attention: the lender carries out its own valuation of the property.

Suppose you buy an apartment for CHF 900’000.–. Your bank nevertheless values it for lending purposes at only CHF 850’000.–. The CHF 50’000.– difference does not disappear simply because your affordability is excellent.

Tip Try our mortgage calculator to estimate your potential monthly payments.

Under the lower-of-cost-or-value principle, financing is calculated using the lower determining value. Any difference between the purchase price and the lending value must therefore be covered by the buyer in addition to the equity required for the financing.

Another lender may nevertheless value the same property differently because its statistical model, comparable data or internal assessment are not exactly the same.

In a mortgage broker vs bank comparison, simply asking “what is your rate?” can therefore cause you to miss a question worth tens of thousands of francs: what value do you assign to my property?

Two offers at the same rate can be very different

Imagine two mortgage offers at 1.50%. At first glance, it is a tie. In reality, they can create two very different commitments.

Compare what you will be able to do after signing

A mortgage should not be judged only on the day you take it out. It should also be assessed in light of a future sale, another purchase or its renewal.

  • What happens if you sell the property before a fixed-rate mortgage reaches maturity?
  • Can the financing be transferred to another property?
  • Are there fees for amending the contract?
  • Can you easily change lender when the mortgage is renewed?
  • Is the mortgage split into several tranches maturing on different dates?

This last point is often overlooked. Splitting a fixed-rate mortgage across several maturity dates may feel reassuring because the entire financing does not need to be renewed at once. However, widely spaced maturities can also make changing lender more difficult: when one tranche matures, another remains tied to the current institution.

In other words, diversifying maturity dates can reduce interest-rate risk while increasing your dependence on the lender. This is exactly the type of factor that belongs in a bank-versus-broker mortgage comparison.

Tip Submit a request now to receive mortgage proposals that can help you buy the property you want.

An exit clause can be worth more than a 0.10% rate difference

Ending a fixed-rate mortgage before maturity can trigger a substantial penalty. Depending on the contract and interest-rate environment, it may run into several thousand or even tens of thousands of francs.

On CHF 700’000.–, a 0.10 percentage-point difference in the rate equals CHF 700.– per year. An unfavourable exit clause can wipe out several years of that saving in a single transaction.

The “best rate” is therefore not automatically the best mortgage.

Bank or broker: the range of lender types also changes

The Swiss mortgage market is not limited to banks. Some insurance companies and pension funds also grant mortgages. They may have different investment objectives and offer different characteristics, particularly for certain fixed terms.

Some insurers and pension institutions offer fixed-rate mortgages with terms of up to 20 or 25 years, whereas many banks stop earlier. Some pension funds nevertheless restrict financing to their own members or to certain loan sizes.

This is rarely mentioned when people ask broker or bank for a mortgage. A broker with a sufficiently broad network may be able to present your application to different categories of lenders. A bank, by definition, is not going to send you to an insurer simply because its offer might suit you better.

Table: bank or mortgage broker for a mortgage in Switzerland

Point comparedDirect with a bankMortgage broker
Credit decisionAccording to the rules of the lender contactedAlways made by the selected lender
Number of credit policies consideredOnePotentially several
Treatment of incomeAccording to the bank’s internal criteriaPossibility of identifying lenders applying different criteria
Property valuationValuation by the lenderPossibility of comparing several lenders where the application allows it
Types of lendersThe bank approachedBanks and, depending on the network, other mortgage lenders
NegotiationYou negotiate directlyPossible competition between partners
ComparisonYou organise it yourselfCentralised
View of contractual termsOnly those of the institutionPossible comparison of the specific features of several contracts
Relationship with the lenderDirect from the outsetThe broker acts as an intermediary during the search

When going directly to a bank can work perfectly well

Your bank gives you a genuinely comparable proposal

Choosing between your bank and a broker should not become an artificial opposition. If your bank finances the amount you need, values the property appropriately, offers good terms and proposes a contract suited to your project, its offer may very well be the best one.

The problem is not obtaining an offer from your bank. The problem is having no basis for knowing whether it is genuinely competitive.

You are willing to do the comparison work yourself

You can of course request several offers directly. For the comparison to be meaningful, however, submit the same application and ask each institution for the same parameters.

Do not compare a ten-year fixed-rate mortgage with a combination of tranches, or an offer based on a lending value of CHF 850’000.– with another calculated on CHF 900’000.–. Otherwise, you are comparing rates for financing that is not actually the same.

Five questions to ask before you choose

Before deciding between a bank or broker, ask these questions. They are often more revealing than the interest-rate question.

  1. What qualifying income do you actually use for my application?
  2. What lending value do you assign to the property?
  3. What is the maximum amount you are prepared to finance?
  4. What would it cost me to exit the contract before maturity?
  5. Will this structure allow me to change lenders easily later?

A sixth question is essential when consulting a broker: what types of institutions will actually be able to assess my application?

You then obtain a far more informative comparison than “Bank A: 1.52%; Bank B: 1.47%”.

Bank or broker: how do you make the decision?

If your situation is straightforward, you understand mortgage financing well and you are prepared to approach several institutions yourself, going directly to banks can work perfectly well.

If, on the other hand, you want your application assessed against several credit policies without organising the search yourself, working with a professional mortgage broker broadens the scope of the comparison.

This can be particularly useful where the application involves variable income, self-employment, an investment property, a property valuation that may be debatable, or simply where the financeable amount is close to the affordability limit.

A broker cannot make an impossible project financeable by magic. However, a rejection by one bank does not always prove that no lender will accept the project. It first shows that the application does not satisfy the credit policy of the institution that assessed it.

Are you preparing to buy a home in Switzerland? Have your borrowing capacity and project reviewed by a mortgage financing specialist. We can analyse your application and then search among our partners for solutions that genuinely match your circumstances.

Receive 3 free mortgage loan proposals

Quick and no-obligation request

Frequently asked questions about choosing a broker or bank

Do you need to use a broker for a mortgage?

No. You can apply for your mortgage directly from a bank. A broker becomes particularly useful when it makes sense to compare your application across several institutions or different assessment methods.

My bank already knows me: is that an advantage?

Yes, particularly because it already holds information about your financial situation. However, that does not mean its financing criteria or terms will be the most favourable. A long-standing relationship therefore does not replace a comparison.

Can a broker obtain a mortgage after a bank has rejected the application?

Sometimes, but never with certainty. Credit policies and affordability calculations vary between lenders. An application rejected by one institution may therefore be acceptable elsewhere. If the financing is objectively too high in relation to income or equity, however, changing intermediary will not remove the problem.

Is the lowest interest rate always the best offer?

No. You should also examine the value assigned to the property, the amount financed, amortisation, fees, maturity dates, exit conditions and the options for changing the financing later.

Can I ask my bank for an offer and also consult a broker?

Yes. This can even provide an excellent basis for comparison, provided the proposals cover the same amount, term and mortgage structure. However, tell the broker which institutions you have already contacted so that unnecessary duplicate applications to the same lender can be avoided.

No article found with your search criteria !

The information in this guide is general in nature. It does not constitute a financing offer, a guarantee that credit will be granted, or personalised legal, tax or financial advice. Acceptance criteria, valuation methods and contractual terms vary according to the lender and the borrower’s circumstances.

Author : Jean
Mortgage expert
Mortgage simulation
Try our mortgage loan calculator and find out how much you can afford
FREE

Brokers in the area